|
Socrates |
|
Hayagriva: ...that Syamasundara treated,
but they're somewhat incomplete, so I will read. I've gone to the
primary sources. He used a college outline series that wasn't really
adequate. So I went to the primary sources, and I'll read a little, and
if you want to comment on it, comment. If you don't feel like commenting
on it, I'll just go on to the next section.
Once a student of Socrates--this is a section on Socrates--said, "I cannot refute you, Socrates." To this Socrates replied, "Say rather that you cannot refute the truth, for Socrates is easily refuted." This is by way of saying that the Absolute Truth is not a subject of mental speculation or personal opinion. The Truth, or the good, for Socrates stands separate from mundane relativities or personal opinion. Prabhupada: That is our opinion. We accept Krsna as the supreme authority, and therefore we cannot refute what Krsna says. And our philosophy is perfect because we follow Krsna. He is the Supreme Perfect. This is our position. In other religious system, taking it our Krsna consciousness movement religious... It is religious, because our religion means the..., to carry out the order of God. That is the sum and substance of religion. We don't manufacture religion, and neither religion can be manufactured. Manufactured religion is useless. That has been described in the Bhagavad-gita, er, Srimad-Bhagavatam as dharma kaitava. Means cheating. So this is not cheating religion. Our basic principle is dharmam tu saksad bhagavat-pranitam. Dharma means the order which is given by God, and if you execute that, that is dharma. Just like law. Law is given by the government. You cannot manufacture law. That is not law. So our perfection is there, how we are executing the order of God cent percent. One who has no conception of God, neither the order of God, they can manufacture religious system. But our system is different. Hayagriva: (aside:) This is picking up fine, the reading? Socrates considers the contemplation of beauty to be an activity of the wise man, but relative beauty in the mundane world is simply a reflection of absolute beauty. In the same way, good in the relative world is simply a reflection of the absolute good. In either case, absolute good or beauty is transcendental. Prabhupada: Yes. That is our opinion. Beauty, knowledge, strength and opulence--everything--they are transcendental. Here, in this material world, it is perverted reflection. Just like the example is the mirage. A fool, animal, is thinking there is water in the desert, and he is running after it, and after sometimes he dies of thirst because there is not. But a sane man knows there is no water; it is simply a reflection by the sunshine, and this foolish animal is running after it. So he does not..., a sane man does not go for this false water. But another thing is that because there is no water in the desert, it does not mean there is no water. Water is there, but not there. Similarly happiness, beauty, opulence--everything is there. That is in the spiritual world. Here it is only a perverted reflection. So generally people have no information of the spiritual world; therefore they imagine something God, something spiritual world. They do not take that "This is imagination, this material world." When Krsna says, tyaktva deham punar janma naiti mam eti, they are reading Bhagavad-gita, but this simple thing they can not understand, that a devotee of Krsna, after giving up this body--the body has to be given up--then what happens? Krsna says mam eti, "He come to Me." And other system says that after death he goes to hell or goes to heaven. So that is to some extent fact. This human life, if he understands Krsna, he goes to the eternal abode--you can take it as heaven or something. Otherwise he remains in this material world to undergo the same cycle of birth and death. That is hell. It can be taken in that way. Hayagriva: According to Socrates, the pursuit of man is the seeking of this absolute good. Basically Socrates is an impersonalist because he does not ultimately define this absolute good as a person, nor does he give the absolute good a personal name. He just calls it "the good." Prabhupada: That is preliminary stage of understanding the Absolute. Because the..., the beginning, Brahman realization, impersonal, and then further advanced Paramatma realization, localized, God is everywhere. And God is everywhere, that's a fact. That is God. But He has got His place, abode. That is God, that goloka eva nivasaty akhilatma-bhuto, that God is Person, He has His own abode, He has his own associates and everything. Difference is that although He is in His abode, He is present everywhere, even within the atom. Andantara-stha-paramanu-cayantara-stham. So Socrates or any other philosopher, they cannot understand the potency of God, how He can remain in His own place, simultaneously in every atom. That is the conception of God. So everywhere He is staying. Everything is His expansion, His energy, the bhumir apo 'nalo vayuh kham mano buddhir eva ca. The material world is bhumir apo 'nalo vayuh--land, water, earth, air. So these are different expansion of God's energy. So He can be present everywhere because His energy is expanded everywhere. So energy and the energetic, they are not different, but at the same time energy is not the energetic. This simultaneously one and different, acintya-bhedabheda-tattva, this is perfect philosophy. Hayagriva: For Socrates, he taught a kind of a process of liberation. For him, liberation meant freedom from passion. Prabhupada: Freedom from? Hayagriva: Passion, passion. Prabhupada: Passion, yes. Hayagriva: And his motto was, "Know thyself." And by knowing oneself through meditation or insight one can gain self-control, and by being self-controlled one can attain happiness. Prabhupada: Yes, that is a fact. Meditation means to analyze oneself--that is real meditation--and find out the Absolute Truth. That is the description in the Vedic literature. Dhyanavasthita-tad-gatena manasa pasyanti yam yogino. Yogi means by his meditation he is seeing the Supreme Truth, Krsna, or God, within himself. Krsna is there, and so a yogi consults Krsna, and Krsna advises him. That is the relationship with yogi. Buddhi-yogam dadami tam. One who is purified, he is seeing Krsna always within himself. That is confirmed in the Brahma-samhita, premanjana-cchurita-bhakti-vilocanena santah sadaiva hrdayesu vilokayanti. A saintly person, advanced, he is seeing Krsna, yam syamasundaram. The very word used, Krsna is syamasundaram, very beautiful blackish, the Personality of Godhead, Syamasundaram. Syama means blackish, but extraordinarily beautiful. That is called syama. Premanjana-cchurita-bhakti-vilocanena santah sadaiva hrdayesu vilokayanti yam syamasundaram acintya-guna-svarupam. Acintaya, unlimited qualities. Govindam adi-purusam tam aham... He is govindam. So it can be realized that He is situated everywhere, at the same time in His person He is always engaged in Vrndavana dancing with the gopis and playing with His friends and talking with His mother, and sometimes as naughty boy He is teasing mother's household affairs. So this is Krsna. Hayagriva: It's been said that Socrates's philosophy is primarily a philosophy of ethics, and that... Prabhupada: Atheist? Hayagriva: Ethics, ethics... Prabhupada: Ethics. Hayagriva: The way, the way to... Prabhupada: Ethics, yes. Hayagriva: The way of action in the world. And the jnana, or knowledge, in itself is not sufficient, but it must be applied and must serve as a basis for action in the world. Prabhupada: Yes, ethics is the basic principle of purification. Unless one does..., knows what is moral and what is immoral... Of course, in this material world everything is immoral, but still we have to distinguish good and bad. That is called regulative principle. Simply by following the regulative principle, if he does not reach the ultimate goal of spiritual life, so that is also not wanted. The real aim is to come to the spiritual platform and become free from the influence of these laws of material nature. So passion is the binding force in the material nature. Just like in the prison house the prisoners are kept sometimes chained by some iron shackles and other method, so material nature has given the chain, shackles, of sex life, passion, rajas tamah. Kama esa krodha esa rajo-guna-samudbhavah. Rajah-gunah means the modes of passion. So modes of passion means kama, lusty desires, and krodha. When the lusty desires are not fulfilled, one becomes angry. But these things are the means of bondage in this material world. In another place it is said, tada rajas-tamo-bhavah kama-lobhadayas ca ye. When one is afflicted with the base material modes of nature, namely rajo-guna and tamo-guna, then he becomes greedy and lusty. So ethics require to get out of the clutches of greediness and lusty desires. Then he comes to the platform of goodness, which will help him to go to the platform of spiritual life. Hayagriva: But is meditation in itself..., would that be sufficient to transcend these lower...? Prabhupada: Yes, meditation, if he seeks after the Supersoul within himself... Hayagriva: Oh. Prabhupada: ...that meditation is perfect. And if he is manufacturing something or bluffing others and bluffing himself by..., in the name of meditation, transcendental, it is useless. It has no value. Hayagriva: Well, he feels that if one knows himself one will be a sadhu, because knowledge is identical with virtue. Prabhupada: Yes. Hayagriva: And through meditation--they call..., he called it arete (?)--a person attains knowledge. Through knowledge a person becomes virtuous. When one is virtuous, he acts in the right way. When one acts properly, he becomes happy. Therefore the enlightened man is a man who is meditative, knowledgeable, virtuous and, because of his proper action, he is happy. Prabhupada: Yes. That is confirmed in the Bhagavad-gita: brahma-bhutah prasannatma na socati na kanksati. This is the symptom of self-realized person. If one is self-realized, he is immediately happy, prasannatma, jolly, because immediately he is on the right. Just like one is going on under some mistaken ideas, and when he comes to the real idea, he becomes very happy: "Oh, so long I was going on such a mistaken idea." So immediately the result will be happiness: "How foolish I was. I was doing like this, doing like that." So right..., as soon as one comes to the right position, he, the symptom is he is prasannatma. What is that prasannatma? Na socati na kanksati. Prasannatma, happiness, means he has no more anything to hanker. Just like Dhruva Maharaja said, svamin krtartho 'smi varam: "I don't want any material benediction." Prahlada Maharaja said, "My Lord, don't tell You want me for any material benefit. I have seen so much afflict. My father was so big materialistic that even the demigods, they were afraid of him. You have finished it within a second. So I am not after these things." So this is real knowledge, that na socati na kanksati, he has no more hankering. The karmis, jnanis, yogis, they have got hankering. The karmis, they are hankering after how to get material wealth, how to get material position, how to get nice woman, how to get nice position. That is karmi. Their business--simply hankering, hankering. Bancruptcy (?). And if they have lost, they cry, "Oh, I have lost it, I have lost it, I have lost." Two business. So when one becomes self-realized, these two things are conspicuous by absence: no more hankering, no more lamenting. The karmis are hankering; the jnanis, they are also expecting to become one with God, to merge into the existence of God. That is also hankering. The yogis, they are hankering after some magic power so they can befool others that he has become God, "I can manufacture gold, I can fly in the sky," and foolish people after them. Intelligent person will see, "What is this perfection? Even if he can fly in the sky, there are so many birds are flying. What is the difference between this flying and that flying?" So he doesn't care. So these are not perfection. But they, people, foolish people, they think it is perfection. If one can say that "I will walk over the sea," actually say it shall happen, thousands and thousands fools will come. Just as, the same thing, that there is a man advertises that he will show how he can bark like dog, people will pay ten rupees ticket and go to see how a man is barking like a dog. But he doesn't hear so many dogs are barking, creating disturbance. So this is going on. Some extraordinary power, showing, making one karmi, jnani, yogi, but a devotee, he is so satisfied in the service of the Lord, he doesn't want anything, all this nonsense. That is perfection. Hayagriva: You once mentioned that Greeks, the ancient Greeks were chased out of India where... They were ksatriyas chased out of India by Parasara Muni, something like that. But Socrates was confronted with a society that on one hand included what were called Sophists--these were more or less mental speculators; they were paid money to philosophize or to speculate--and humanists, who said, "Man is the measure of all things." They..., no belief in God or any higher force; nothing beside man. And with the demigod worshipers, the Greek pantheon of gods were very much like the demigods described in the Vedic literatures, like Zeus was like Indra, and Athena was like Sarasvati. They retained..., the Greeks retained their worship of the demigods, but there is no mention of a Supreme God under whom everyone else served, and Socrates, on..., neglected the worship of these demigods. He felt that there was no use in worshiping the demigods, and he stressed meditation on the self, on the highest good which resides in the heart, which must correspond to the Paramatma. Prabhupada: Yes. Hayagriva: And so in teaching this he was teaching something radically different, and this is one of the reasons that he was condemned to death--for blaspheming the demigods, for blaspheming the gods. He felt that the worship of these gods did not lead to self-realization at all. Prabhupada: Yes. That's a fact. That is confirmed in the Bhagavad-gita: kamais tais tair hrta-jnanah tyajante anya-devatah. They worship other demigods, being too much lusty. Because the demigod is worshiped for some material benefit. So they have been described as hrta-jnanah. Hrta-jnanah means one who has lost his intelligence. Actually it is so. Suppose by worshiping a demigod, Sarasvati, the goddess of learning, so you get the opportunity of being a, becoming a very nice scholar. But how long you shall remain scholar? As soon as the body is finished, your whole scholarship is finished. Then you have to accept another body, and you have to act according to that body. So how you have..., this scholarship will help you? But if you worship God, as Krsna says, that janma karma ca me divyam yo janati tattvatah... To worship God means to know God, actually what is God, more perfect--how He is managing, how material nature is working under Him. People cannot even imagine that God can be person, but here is everything person. Mayadhyaksena prakrtih suyate sa-caracaram: "Under My supervision the material nature is working." So these impersonalists or less intelligent persons, they cannot understand that how a person can dictate the wonderful activities of the material nature; therefore they remain impersonalist. But actually, person. That is the understanding of Bhagavad-gita. God is person. Mattah parataram nanyat kincid asti dhananjaya: "There is no more superior authority than Me." So when He says mattah, that means there is a person, person. So... Hayagriva: Bhakta. Prabhupada: Huh? Hayagriva: Bhakta. Prabhupada: No, Krsna, God. Hayagriva: Yes. Prabhupada: God is person. Hayagriva: Yes. Prabhupada: And He says, mattah parataram nanyat kincid asti dhananjaya: "There is no more superior authority than Me." Aham sarvasya prabhavo mattah sarvam pravartate: "I am the origin of everything. Everything emanates from Me." And the Vedanta-sutra confirms, "The Absolute Truth is that from which everything comes," janmady asya yatah. So the Absolute Truth is person, and Arjuna, when he understood Bhagavad-gita, he addressed Krsna, param brahma. That is Absolute Truth. Param brahma param dhama pavitram paramam bhavan. So really understanding Absolute Truth means to understand His personal feature. He has got three features: impersonal feature, localized feature and personal feature. So brahmeti paramatmeti bhagavan iti sabdyate. All of them are the same truth, spiritual truth, but different phases or different features. The example is given, just like you see one mountain from a very distant place, very distant place, you see the hazy something like cloud. Then you come nearer, you see something green, there are trees, like that. And if you will come still nearer, you will see, "No. It is not only trees and hazy but there are houses, there are men, there are animals." So actually the same thing, the mountain from a distant place, but because one is far away from the mountain, he sees the same mountains are impersonal, and if he comes little nearer, then he sees Paramatma, personal within, present everywhere. And when he comes again still, he sees the same person is still there; He is dancing and playing. This is the difference. Hayagriva: So through jnana, through the path of jnana, Socrates may have realized Brahman, he may have realized Paramatma... Prabhupada: Yes. Hayagriva: ...but there was no way to realize... Prabhupada: No, there is way... Hayagriva: ...Krsna. Prabhupada: ...there is way, if he makes further advancement. The same example, the same mountain is there. From a distant place you will say hazy cloud; nearer you see something green, there are trees; and still you go farther, you will see everything perfectly. Hayagriva: But I thought Krsna can only be realized through bhakti, through... Prabhupada: Yes. Hayagriva: ...devotion. Prabhupada: Yes. You can not enter in Krsna's place without being a purified bhakta. Bhaktya mam abhijanati. That is stated in the Bhagavad-gita. He never says that by jnana or by karma or by yoga one can understand Him. It is clearly stated, in many sastra, bhaktya mam abhijanati: only through devotional service one can understand Krsna. The personal abode of Krsna is especially reserved for the bhaktas. Therefore all jnanis, yogis, karmis, they cannot; they remain outside, that there is the sunshine and the sun. To enter into the sun is not so easy thing, but sunshine anyone can remain. The temperature is not so hot; you can tolerate it. But although the sunshine and the sun not different, in the sunshine, sun globe, if you enter, if you have go the power to enter, the same light and same temperature... Not same, I mean to say, temperature and light. So the temperature of sunshine, light and temperature, is not the same as the temperature and light in the sun globe. (break) Hayagriva: Now Socrates, as a teacher, in addition to believing in the value of insight or meditation, Socrates also believed that knowledge can be imparted from one person to another. He therefore believed in the role of a guru or teacher, which he himself was for many people. He believed also in good association amongst people who were interested in self-realization, and he followed the method known as the Socratic dialogue as a means for evoking the truth. Now, he would use a method called Socratic irony, in which he himself, Socrates, would pose himself as an ignorant person and would ask questions of his young disciples. He would never offer the answers, but would try to draw the answers out of his disciples, and this was called the mayudic (?) method. So he considered himself to be a kind of midwife--in fact his mother was a midwife--who would draw the truth from the repository in the soul. He felt that the truth was there within but had to be drawn out, and that the truth is dormant within everyone, that the individual possesses the truth previous to birth in an existence previous to earthly existence. Prabhupada: Yes. So almost similar to our method, because we advised, we advised in this Vedic principle, that for the truth one must approach a guru. That is the version everywhere. In Bhagavad-gita also, same instruction is there:
tad viddhi
pranipatena
pariprasnena sevaya upadeksyanti tad jnanam jnaninas tattva-darsinah
So you have to approach a guru who knows
the Absolute Truth. "Knows" means he has seen. Just like in our daily
life, direct perception to see something, people argue on that, that
"Can you show me God?" That is the tendency, that direct perception. So
the direct perception is possible by advanced devotion. There is no
difficulty because, as I have already explained, santah sadaiva hrdayesu
vilokayanti. Constantly he is seeing the Supreme Personality of Godhead,
Syamasundara. So there is a state when one can constantly see the
Supreme Lord as Paramatma sitting within his heart and taking advice
from Him. Krsna also confirms this: buddhi-yogam dadami tam. He talks.
So by meditation, if it is actually meditation to search out the
Absolute Truth within the heart, then he can meet. That is the yoga
practice. Yoga practice means concentrating the mind to see the
Supersoul within. Therefore he has to control the activities of the
senses from all other engagements. Then it is possible. Yoga practice,
this dhyana, dharana, asana, pranayama, these are why? Simply to
concentrate the mind, focusing toward the Paramatma, and then, when is
perfect, he always sees. Therefore Krsna confirms it in the
Bhagavad-gita:
yoginam api
sarvesam
mad-gatenantar-atmana sraddhavan bhajate yo mam sa me yuktatamo matah
"Of all the yogis, one who has learned to
see Me within himself, he is first class." Others are bogus. The
perfection of yoga means to see God within himself. That is perfection
of yoga. So this process, as Socrates used to give chance to his
disciple, that is good process, to give him chance to develop his
understanding. The teacher helps. Just like the father and mother give
the child. First of all he helps, taking his hand, "Now walk, walk," and
sometimes he gives him pleasure: "Now you walk. Let me see how you walk.
Now you walk." Although he sometimes falls down, but a father will
encourage, "Oh, you are very nice. Stand up, stand up again. Walk." So
give chance to the disciple how they can think properly to go back to
home, back to Godhead, teacher is giving instruction and tries to see
how he has developed. So that process is natural. And another process is
that suppose a man comes to argue, so you should give him first chance,
"All right, you say what is the import of these verses." Then he can
understand his position, where he is. Then he captures him. Because an
expert, he knows how to capture the fool. So let the fool first of all
go on, talk all nonsense, then he'll understand where he is and he will
capture. That is also a process.
Hayagriva: Socrates, in a very famous allegory or metaphor, pictures humanity living in a dark cave, and the teacher has seen the light outside of the cave. He knows that there's something outside the cave that is light, and he may return to the cave to tell people in the cave that this is darkness. And the people in the cave, many of them would consider him to be crazy for speaking of such a thing as the light outside of the cave, and that this was a very, conceivably a very dangerous position to be in. Prabhupada: But actually that is the fact. Just like we are say so many times, Dr. Frog. A frog within the dark well, he is thinking, "Here is everything." And if he is informed, "Oh, there is big miles of water, Atlantic Ocean," so this Dr. Frog, from within the well he has never seen the Atlantic Ocean, and he cannot conceive that the water can be so expansive. So therefore those who are in the dark well, for them it is surprising that what is the light outside. But that's a fact. And one who has fallen, he is in the..., if he is crying that "I am fallen," so it is said that the man outside, he drops a rope, that "You catch this rope and I shall take it out." But he does not catch up. Just like we are presenting that you, everyone in the material world, you are suffering, you take, catch up this Krsna consciousness. They are refusing, or they do not admit; that is going on. But if one is fortunate, he can catch up the rope, and the man wants to help him, he can get him out. But he has to catch up. It is Krsna's advice also, that "You are crying, you are suffering, you are finding, trying to find out how your suffering will be ended." That materialist, they are doing their own way, and the impersonalists, they are doing in their own way; the yogis, they are doing in their own way. Everyone is trying to get out of the suffering. But when Krsna says that these things will not help you, sarva-dharman parityajya mam ekam saranam vraja, he does not catch up. That is his misfortune. God Himself says that "You take." "You take Me" means by His instruction in the Bhagavad-gita. "You take to Me, you will be saved." But they will not. That is their obstinacy. And the Vedas therefore says, tamasi ma jyotir gamah: "Don't remain in the dark well. You come out to the light." But they will not come to the light. They want to remain in the dark well. And if you want to become perfect, that is their misfortune. Within this material world it is darkness, just like the, just now it is evening. It is giving us that actually it is dark. Because Krsna has supplied the sun, moon, therefore it is light. But there is another place where, without sun, without moon, you will get light. That is stated in the Bhagavad-gita: na yatra bhasayate suryo, na pavakah, like that, there is a na yatra bhasa, tad dhama paramam, "That is My kingdom." So everything is Krsna's kingdom, but there is specially, that there is no need of sunshine, there is no need of moonshine, there is no need of electric light; it is all effulgent. So He is giving the information, but these rascals will not take. They want to make adjustment in the darkness of night. How it is possible? This is teaching also the nature's way of work. The sun is in the sky, but the arrangement is such that twelve hours it is darkness and twelve hours it is light. But sun is there always. There is no doubt about it. But the arrangement, this is just to convince us that actually it is dark. With the sunshine it is sometimes day and sunny. Similarly, happiness can be by the..., to remain under this sunshine, under the illumination of Krsna. That is happiness, Krsna consciousness. And if you want to be happy in darkness... Just like in darkness at night the only happiness is sleeping and sex, that's all. There is no other happiness. And when there was dark in New York, electricity failed, and so many women became pregnant. (laughs) Yes. In the darkness this is the happiness: either you sleep or you enjoy sex. That is happiness. That is material world; therefore it is darkness. That is said in the Srimad-Bhagavatam:
srotavyadini
rajendra
nrnam santi sahasrasah apasyatam atma-tattvam grhesu grha-medhinam
nidraya hriyate
naktam
vyavayena ca va vayah diva carthehaya rajan kutumba-bharanena va
These materialistic persons, they have
got many things to hear, srotavyadini, huge, big, big volumes of
newspaper, so many rascal information. Why they have got so many
engagement? Apasyatam atma-tattvam: because they do not know what is
self-realization. Grhesu grha-medhinam. They think that to live in this
family life surrounded by wife, children, friends, this is life. So
better use this newspaper and talk all nonsense and waste time. Their
engagement is nidraya. At night they sleep or enjoy sex, nidraya hriyate
naktam vyavayena, and in daytime they hanker after money, runs the
motorcar head-break speed, neck-break speed.
Hayagriva: Breakneck. Prabhupada: Breakneck. And then what is the business? Searching out some means of food, exactly like the hog, he is loitering here and there, "Where is stool? Where is stool? Where is stool?" And this is going on in the polished way as civilization. There is so much risk, as running these cars so many people are dying. There is record, it is very dangerous. At least I feel as soon as I go to the street, it is dangerous. The motorcar are running so speedy, and what is the business? The business is where to find out food. So therefore it is condemned that this kind of civilization is hoggish civilization. This hog is running after, "Where is stool? Where is stool? Where is stool?" And you are running in a car. The same. Purpose is the same: "Where is stool?" Purpose is the same. Therefore this is not advancement of civilization. Advancement of civilization is, as Krsna advises, that you require food, so produce food grain. Remain wherever you are. You can produce food grain anywhere, a little labor. And keep cows, go-raksya, krsi-go-raksya vanijyam vaisya-karma svabhava-jam. Solve your problem like... Produce your food wherever you are there. Till little, little labor, and you will get your whole year's food. And distribute the food to the animal, cow, and eat yourself. The cow will eat the refuse. You take the rice, and the skin you give to the cow. From dahl you take the grain, and the skin you give to the... And fruit, you take the fruit, and the skin you give to the cow, and he will give you milk. So why should you kill him? Milk is the miraculous food; therefore Krsna says krsi-go-raksya vanijyam vaisya. Give protection to the cow, take milk from it, and eat food grains--your food problem is solved. Where is food problem? Why should you invent such civilization always full of anxieties, running the car here and there, and fight with other nation, and economic development? What is this civilization? Therefore we require to take to Krsna consciousness to become happy every way--economically, philosophically, religiously, culturally, everything. That is Krsna consciousness. Hayagriva: One last point on Socrates. For Socrates... Prabhupada: Now this so-called civilization is darkness. That is my point. Hayagriva: Yes.
Prabhupada: It is not in the light. They
are fighting within darkness. Just like if immediately this room become
dark, everyone (indistinct). There is fighting. Stop it. You are asking
me, "Prabhupada, where you are?" I say "Here," and you are going in the
other room.
Hayagriva: Well he pictures in the cave the, something like a cinema, on the wall of the cave... Prabhupada: Yes. Hayagriva: ...and everyone is sitting in the cave looking, absorbed in the cinema, these forms that are not actual forms but are imitation forms. Prabhupada: But that means darkness. Hayagriva: Uh huh. Prabhupada: Darkness, you are saying, "Prabhupada, I am here," and I am looking here: "Where you are?" So that is the position of darkness. Everything you see, it is not clear. That is darkness. Therefore Vedic version is, "Don't remain in darkness. Come to the light." That light is guru. Ajnana-timirandhasya jnananjana-salakaya. This is guru's description. When we are in darkness of ignorance the guru, spiritual master, ignites the torch of knowledge. Ajnana-timirandhasya jnananjana-salaka. Salakaya means torch. Then he sees, "Oh, things are like this." In this way, when he becomes self-realized, brahma-bhu, then he becomes happy, brahma-bhutah prasannatma na socati. That is civilization, to get the light. And to remain in the darkness and struggle for existence, that is not civilization; that is animal life. It has no value. That is going on. Therefore we are trying to give Krsna consciousness, the greatest contribution to the human society. Krsna consciousness we are not manufacturing, we are not bluffing like other swamis and yogis and philosophers. We are simply carrying the light, torchlight, which Krsna has given. That's all. So our business is very easy--very easy and beneficial and practical. Hayagriva: The good that Socrates speaks of is not the same as sattva-guna. This is a quotation from The Republic. Socrates says, "This, then, which gives to the objects of knowledge their truth and to him who knows them his power of knowing is the form or essential nature of goodness." Prabhupada: Yes. Hayagriva: "It is the cause of knowledge and truth, and so while he may think of it as an object of knowledge, he would do well to regard it as something beyond truth and knowledge, and precious as these both are, of still higher worth. And just as in our analogy light and vision were to be thought of like the sun, but not identical with it, so here both knowledge and truth are to be regarded as like the good, but to identify either with the good is wrong. The good must hold a yet higher place of honor. The objects of knowledge derive from the good not only their power of being known, but their very being and reality, and goodness is not the same thing as being, but even beyond being, surpassing it in dignity and power." Prabhupada: Yes. So goodness is the position where you can get knowledge. And passion and ignorance is not the platform of knowledge. Therefore the endeavor should be how to bring persons in the basic or base platform, ignorance and passion. So this is very easily done by our, this Krsna consciousness movement. If one hears about Krsna, or God, then gradually he becomes freed from the clutches of darkness and passion, and actually he then comes to the platform of goodness. And when he is perfectly in goodness, then this passion and ignorance and their by-products cannot touch him. Tada rajas-tamo-bhavah kama-lobhadayas ca ye.
nasta-prayesv
abhadresu
nityam bhagavata-sevaya bhagavaty uttama-sloke bhaktir bhavati naisthiki
tada rajas-tamo-bhavah
kama-lobhadayas ca ye ceta etair anaviddham...
If we hear Bhagavatam, Bhagavad-gita
regularly, then we become free from the effects of the modes of
ignorance and passion, gradually, although it takes... But it is sure.
The more you hear about Krsna, or--Krsna means His instruction or about
Him, what He is--the more you become purified. So that is the test, that
how one has become purified means one is purified from the base quality
of passion and ignorance, means that he is no more attacked by
greediness and passion. That is the test. That means he is free from the
base qualities, and he is situated, ceta etair anaviddham sthitam sattve
prasidati. When he is no more disturbed by these base qualities of
passion and greediness, then he is happy. Then he becomes happy. Ceta
etair anavi..., sthitasya, that is goodness. That is goodness. Then he
is happy, happiness, that the ultimate stage of goodness is
brahma-bhutah, to realize himself, realize God. So goodness, one must
come to the platform of goodness. So we are therefore asking people to
give up these base qualitative activities--illicit sex and meat-eating
and drinking or intoxication and gambling. These are base qualities. So
anyone gives up these qualities, he remains in the sattva-guna. And then
if he is promoted farther, just like Socrates said that goodness is not
all, that still you have to..., and that is bhakti. Then his realization
is perfect. He becomes liberated, and then gradually he develops love of
God, then he is in the original state. Bhaktir hitva anyatha. As mukti,
liberation, means that to be free from this all nonsense engagements.
Nitya-baddha, they are engaged, all these karmis, jnanis, yogis, they
are simply engaged in some false engagements to become happy. So when
one is free from these false engagements, then he is in the liberated
state. Mukti means muktir hitva anyatha rupam. Anyatha rupam means he is
acting otherwise. So one has to come to the real position, not work, act
otherwise. So he is eternal servant of Krsna. When he fully engage
himself in the service of Krsna, then he is liberated, and if he keeps
himself, then nobody can touch, the maya cannot touch. Daivi hy esa
gunamayi mama maya. Maya is very strong, but if one keeps in touch with
Krsna constantly, maya has no jurisdiction. Mayam etam taranti te. This
is perfection of life.
Hayagriva: Transcendental to the modes. Prabhupada: Yes. No more affected by the modes of material nature. Sa gunan samatityaitan brahma-bhuyaya kalpate. Such person is transcendental to the modes of material nature. Sa gunan samatityaitan brahma. That is brahma-bhutah stage. So every devotee, if he is strictly following the rules and regulation, he is in the brahma-bhutah stage. Just like there is epidemic, but one who has taken the vaccine, the epidemic cannot touch it. So that is like that. Brahma, when you come to the brahma-bhutah state, let..., there may be maya, there may be so many activities of ignorance and passion--he has nothing to do with. He is free. That is brahma-bhutah state. That is wanted. That is perfection. Hayagriva: So that's the conclusion of the additional notes on Socrates, Srila Prabhupada. Prabhupada: Yes, it was very, very nice. Hayagriva: And if new philosophers that we will present eventually, oh, um, I don't know if these were ever... Prabhupada: Actually the main philosophy is Socrates. He is (indistinct). Hayagriva: Socrates, Plato, Aristotle, these have been done. Just a little, a few additions. But then there's Plotinus, Origen, and Augustine, and these were the three philosophers who shaped Christian thought or Catholic, the Church thought, Church fathers, and St. Anselm, St. Thomas Aquinas, Scotus and Eckhart, these are Christian... Prabhupada: So they are not philosopher; they are Christian with different point of views. So we are not going to discuss with a person he is from the stand..., deviating from the standard way and thinking in their mental speculation. Hayagriva: But these, these are considered philosophers... Prabhupada: Considered, but because they belong to a certain sect of religion... Hayagriva: Because they are followers of Christ? Prabhupada: Yes. And they are deviating from the original Christian father, so they are useless. Hayagriva: They do, they do deviate. They... Prabhupada: No, you can not deviate. Then no more you are Christian. So you can..., you have no platform to talk from the Christianity. Therefore they should be rejected. Hayagriva: Uh huh. So Plotinus was not Christian, neither was Origen... Prabhupada: If you say Christian, you must follow the four..., ten commandments of Christ. If you don't follow, you make your own ways to escape, then you are no longer Christian. So you cannot talk. Hayagriva: But Augustine was one of the ones who maintained that animals do not have souls. Prabhupada: Therefore he is a rascal. Hayagriva: Yes. Prabhupada: He is a rascal. Hayagriva: And this was accepted... Prabhupada: Now, what do you, what do you use, what the use to talking with a rascal? It is waste of time. (end)
|